Home
News
Tesla Disputed Edmunds Tests, Edmunds Did Them Again: See The Results
The electric car company said Edmunds had to drive them until they stopped. Well…

Gustavo Henrique Ruffo 
By: Gustavo Henrique Ruffo
Mar 27, 2021 at 6:57pm ET
Add InsideEVs as a preferred source in Google
- (https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?url=https%3A%2F%2Finsideevs.com%2Fnews%2F496740%2Ftesla-disputed-edmunds-tests-results%2F&text=Tesla%20Disputed%20Edmunds%20Tests%2C%20Edmunds%20Did%20Them%20Again%3A%20See%20The%20Results&via=InsideEVs)
- copy
Share
Comment
Edmunds achieved more than making huge waves in the media when its real-world EV range tests revealed no Tesla could match its EPA range. It got Tesla to contact it, something that does not happen often since the company killed its PR department. Tesla disputed the results, arguing that the cars should be run until they were not able to move anymore. Edmunds accepted the challenge and did new tests on a track. Tesla will hate the results.
The automaker’s main argument was that there is a battery buffer that should have been considered to achieve the EPA range. Since that buffer is also present in other vehicles, Edmunds also took them to the test track in the Mohave desert. All cars were run by all test drivers at the same temperatures.

Besides a Model Y Performance, a Model 3 Standard Range Plus, and a Model 3 Long Range, Edmunds also put a VW ID.4 First Edition and a Ford Mustang Mach-E AWD Extended Range to the test.
The test consisted of driving all the cars at 65 mph (105 km/h) on a 7.5-mile-long closed-course oval. When these cars reached zero charge, Edmunds started counting how much further they could run with the battery buffer at the set speed. When they were no longer able to run at 65 mph, they were driven until they could no longer move.

The Tesla vehicles run 10.3 miles to 22 miles more after reaching zero charge on the dashboard under 65 miles. They were the three EVs to have more range left after that point. When the EVs could not maintain that speed anymore, the Model Y Performance lost its place in the ranking to the ID.4. While the VW ran 12.9 mi, the Model Y ran 12.6 mi.
Although those are interesting numbers, Edmunds had to add them to what the vehicles had achieved on the track.

Only one of the Teslas tested at the Mohave desert could reach its EPA range. It was the Model 3 Long Range, which achieved 343 mi. Its official EPA range is 353 mi, which will certainly sound strange. Technically speaking, it did not reach its official range. Edmunds must have considered a percent difference as acceptable to say it did hit its EPA range.
The others wouldn’t get there even if Edmunds counted the buffer and was indulgent with their numbers. Doing that, the Model Y Performance would reach 263 mi of range against an EPA range of 291 mi. The Model 3 Standard Range Plus would achieve 232 mi instead of the 250 its EPA range promises. Although the Model 3 Performance was not at the test track, it would get 256 mi, a lot less compared to its 310-mi EPA number.

To make matters even more complicated, Edmunds took the Model Y Performance and the Model 3 Long Range to its real-world EV range test loop, and the cars run even less than they did on track after reaching zero charge and driving to a halt. It should be right the opposite.
According to what Tesla engineers told Edmunds, their cars have no defined buffer, which is a factor to consider in this case. We have already mentioned that Tesla works with a virtual battery buffer on April 13, 2020. The other ones would be ambient temperature, driving style, and instantaneous conditions. The only part that makes sense is the variable buffer.
More Edmunds Videos:
This Review States The VW ID.4 Is Much Better Than The Tesla Model Y
Tesla Fails To Meet EPA Range With All Its Cars In Edmunds' Tests
What do you think?
View
Comments
As Alistair Weaver stresses in the video, what this shows is that you can’t just rely on government figures. We have gone even further than Edmunds’ editor-in-chief when we recommended that EVs have specific testing rules that take them into full consideration and are able to determine how energy-efficient they really are.
Image credits: Edmunds.com/teslachallenge
Gallery: Edmunds Repeats Its Real-World Tests To Check How Teslas Fare

5

We want your opinion!
What would you like to see on Insideevs.com?
Take our 3 minute survey.
- The InsideEVs team
Share this Story
- (https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?url=https%3A%2F%2Finsideevs.com%2Fnews%2F496740%2Ftesla-disputed-edmunds-tests-results%2F&text=Tesla%20Disputed%20Edmunds%20Tests%2C%20Edmunds%20Did%20Them%20Again%3A%20See%20The%20Results&via=InsideEVs)
- copy
GO TO COMMENTS
(
)
Got a tip for us? Email: tips@insideevs.com
View all comments ( )
Trending

Lucid Is Slashing $15,000 Off The Gravity, But The Deal Won’t Last Long

The Remnants Of The Electric Saab That Never Was Are Going Up For Auction

What We Both Thought After Driving The Rivian R2

Aptera Finally Built Its First Car For Customer Delivery
Latest Stories
- The U.S. Let Volvo Keep Selling Cars. Polestar Got A No. What About Mercedes? Nov 22 - News -
- Tesla FSD V15 Makes Your Drive Look Like Grand Theft Auto Nov 22 - News -
- Waymo Is Recalling Its Robotaxis Because They're Not Great At Dealing With Human Instructions Nov 21 - Autonomous Vehicles -
- This EV-Swapped 1967 Porsche 912 Has 300 HP And A Split Battery Pack Nov 21 - News -
- This Plug-In Hybrid SUV Towed A Boeing 747 On Only 2 Wheels. Yes, Really. Nov 21 - Towing -
- BYD's Latest SUV Can Hide Its Steering Wheel When You Don't Need It Nov 20 - China -
- What We Both Thought After Driving The Rivian R2 Nov 20 - Podcast -
RECOMMENDED FOR YOU

The Best EV Lease And Finance Deals In November 2026

The U.S. Let Volvo Keep Selling Cars. Polestar Got A No. What About Mercedes?

Tesla Model 3 Maintenance Guide: What Needs Servicing And What Doesn't

Waymo Is Recalling Its Robotaxis Because They're Not Great At Dealing With Human Instructions

Tesla FSD V15 Makes Your Drive Look Like Grand Theft Auto

This EV-Swapped 1967 Porsche 912 Has 300 HP And A Split Battery Pack

Tesla's Driverless Cybercab Is Now Available In Dallas