Las Vegas Woman Returns Her Tesla After Lease Is Up. Then She Sees What They Charge Her For ‘Minor Dings’
“The scratches on the tires I knew about, the tread I thought I could get away with, and the bumper I didn't think they would see.”
EVs are supposed to save drivers money on fuel and maintenance. But when Tesla tallied up a loyal customer’s “wear and tear” on her leased Model Y, the bill told a different story, leaving thousands missing from her bank account in a single line item.
When it came time to trade in her Model 3 for a 2026 Model Y, Cindy McNabb (@cindymae.lv) knew she was going to face some charges for extra mileage and some dings and scrapes that accumulated over her three years of driving. However, she was still surprised when the total reached nearly $4,000.
“I was prepared for something around this amount, because I know I did go over a lot of my miles,” she said in the TikTok clip that’s been viewed more than 85,000 times. “The scratches on the tires I knew about, the tread I thought I could get away with, and the bumper I didn't think they would see.”
A TikTok Breakdown Of Tesla’s Math
In her TikTok video, McNabb walked viewers through the inspection charges line by line. Tesla flagged two curb-rashed rims at $85 each and required two replacement tires at $391 each after the “penny test” showed low tread. A barely-visible dent on the front bumper turned into the most expensive line item at nearly $1,000 for a replacement.
Tesla also initially attempted to charge $564 for aftermarket window tint, a modification common in sunny states like Nevada but not permitted under Tesla’s lease return policy. She eventually persuaded them to remove that charge after having the tint stripped.
Now Trending
The real kicker came with mileage. McNabb’s three-year lease included 12,000 miles per year, but she drove nearly 45,000 miles during that period, exceeding the agreed-upon limit by around 9,000 miles. At $0.25 per mile, Tesla charged $2,250 just for the overage. When everything was added together, her final bill totaled $3,758.98.
FROM THE TRENDING NEWS DESK
Viral bits from across the social media landscape
Our team of experts tracks what's trending so you don't have to—from viral videos to online debates that have everyone talking.
That number, she joked, was unforgettable because Tesla made sure to collect “the extra 98 cents.”
Tesla’s own lease return guide clearly outlines the expectations. Lessees are required to schedule a final inspection, during which photos will be taken to document the tire tread, paint chips, bumper scuffs and interior condition. The company warns that aftermarket modifications such as window tint, wraps or non-factory wheels must be removed before return. Tesla also charges $0.25 per mile for exceeding agreed-upon mileage limits, a rate similar to those of luxury brands like BMW or Mercedes-Benz.
Disposition fees, another common industry cost, typically range from $350 to $400, though Tesla appears to stick to $395. Tesla sometimes waives them when customers roll into another Tesla lease, which was the case for McNabb. She also received a $500 credit toward damage charges, a policy Tesla offers to encourage brand loyalty.
How Tesla Compares With Other Automakers
Lease return sticker shock is not unique to Tesla. Consumer Reports notes that nearly all automakers charge for excess mileage, worn tires and cosmetic damage beyond “normal wear and tear.” Toyota Financial Services and Honda both impose mileage penalties of between 15 and 20 cents per mile, slightly less than Tesla’s 25 cents, while premium brands typically charge 25-30 cents. Tire replacement is another near-universal charge, with lessees advised to replace tires before inspection if tread depth is below 4/32 of an inch.
Where Tesla differs is in its handling of modifications. Many automakers prohibit aftermarket tint, wraps, and rims, but customers have described Tesla’s enforcement as particularly strict. Even removable items, such as sunshades or screen protectors, can sometimes trigger inspection notes, according to lease return forums.
McNabb’s story also raises the larger question of whether leasing an EV is worth it. Leasing has become popular among EV drivers, in part because of federal tax credits, which automakers can pass through to lessees regardless of their income or tax liability. It also provides drivers with a way to upgrade every three years as EV technology continues to evolve.
But the downside comes at turn-in time. Overages on mileage and damage can erase the financial advantage of lower monthly payments. Analysis from AutoTrader found that return costs can easily climb toward $1,500, and those who drive more than the average annual mileage can easily double or triple that figure.
For EVs specifically, concerns like battery health and range degradation are less often penalized directly in lease returns. Instead, it’s the same age-old issues, such as wheels, tires and body panels, that bring the most considerable costs.
Consumer advocates recommend obtaining a pre-inspection several months before the lease end date, making small cosmetic repairs at a local body shop before Tesla’s inspection, and accurately estimating mileage needs upfront. Buying extra miles at lease signing is often cheaper than paying overages later.
For Tesla drivers approaching the end of a lease, McNabb’s experience is a reminder: The EV revolution might change how you power your car, but it hasn’t changed how lease returns work.
InsideEVs reached out to McNabb via email.
RECOMMENDED FOR YOU
The Best Cheap Used EVs In 2026: Top Budget-Friendly EV Deals
China’s Rolls-Royce Rival May Have Found A Shortcut Into Europe
The 17 Cheapest Electric Cars In 2026
Tesla FSD Has A Real Rival. But It Drives Very Differently
The Battery In This 2019 Model 3 Looks Heavily Degraded. But It's Not That Simple
Hyundai’s New ‘Pleos’ Infotainment System Gets All The Right Features
Stranded In -35°F: Here’s How Long A Tesla Model 3 Can Keep You Warm