Home
Features
Opinion
Nikola's Hydrogen Truck Vs. Tesla's Electric Semi
How do these two future vehicles stack up?

EVANNEX 
By: EVANNEX
Jun 25, 2020 at 8:23am ET
Add InsideEVs as a preferred source in Google
- (https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?url=https%3A%2F%2Finsideevs.com%2Ffeatures%2F430705%2Ftesla-semi-versus-nikola-semi%2F&text=Nikola%27s%20Hydrogen%20Truck%20Vs.%20Tesla%27s%20Electric%20Semi&via=InsideEVs)
- copy
Share
Comment
This article comes to us courtesy of EVANNEX, which makes and sells aftermarket Tesla accessories. The opinions expressed therein are not necessarily our own at InsideEVs, nor have we been paid by EVANNEX to publish these articles. We find the company's perspective as an aftermarket supplier of Tesla accessories interesting and are willing to share its content free of charge. Enjoy!
More Nikola News:
Nikola Motors Factory In Coolidge, Arizona To Break Ground On July 23
Bob Lutz Comments On 'Mass Hysteria' Surrounding Tesla, Nikola Stocks
Posted on EVANNEX on June 25, 2020 by Denis Gurskiy
Semi-trucks might not be the sexiest of vehicles but they represent a key market for cleaner transport. For carbon emissions to drop worldwide, semi-trucks will be crucial. Recently, there's been a lot of media buzz about the Tesla Semi and Nikola One. Yet these two Semi-trucks are entering the segment with two completely different implementations. Tesla is all-electric while Nikola is choosing the more controversial hydrogen fuel cell route. So which will be better?

Source: EVBite
Similar to most Class 8 trucks, both the One and Semi will be able to tow up to 80,000 lbs. Nikola claims that their Semi will hit 60 mph in 30 seconds, whereas Tesla states their Semi will do it in just 20 seconds. Nikola is promising a range of between 500-750 miles (this means, however, refueling at non-existent hydrogen stations). Meanwhile, Tesla will have two different versions of their Semi, one with a range of 300 miles and another with a range 500 miles.
Price is another question mark for Nikola — the company hasn't provided the price of their semi-truck. Tesla, on the other hand, has stated that their 300-mile version would cost around $150,000 while their 500-mile version would start at about $180,000. To put this in perspective, pricing of a Freighligher Cascadia, one of the most popular semis on the road right now, is anywhere between $130,000 to $160,000. So Tesla appears to be within a typical, industry-standard price range. As for Nikola, the jury is still out.
![]()
YouTube: EVBite
Perhaps the biggest differentiator between the two, and probably most relevant in the decision-making process, is the powertrain. The Tesla Semi uses an all-electric approach while the Nikola One uses a hydrogen fuel cell system (similar to the low-selling Toyota Mirai).
Electric powertrains have some significant advantages over hydrogen fuel cell technology. Most importantly, they're far more energy-efficient. To put it simply, while the process of using hydrogen as a fuel source remains more energy-efficient than gasoline, it's still less efficient than a fully electric system (by far).

Source: Transport & Environment
Another issue: the lack of hydrogen refueling stations. According to the Department of Energy, there are only 49 hydrogen fueling stations in North America, with almost all of them within California. Meanwhile, Tesla's Supercharger Network is massive. In addition, there's also a fast-growing EV charging infrastructure that's non-Tesla specific (but still compatible with Tesla) as well.
At this point in time, the biggest "positive" that hydrogen has over fully electric is faster refueling time — assuming you can find a station. But keep in mind: battery and charging tech has rapidly been improving charging times. And the efficiency of battery electric vehicles remains a massive advantage. By the way, it's not just Tesla that feels this way. This chart (see below) from Volkswagen explains why their vote is for electric instead of hydrogen fuel cells.

Source: Volkswagen
Not surprisingly, with all these strikes against hydrogen, Nikola hasn't put all its eggs in one basket. While they're definitely pushing for hydrogen fuel cells, they plan to have electric versions of their Nikola Two and Nikola Tre, albeit with shorter ranges compared to their hydrogen counterparts.
What do you think?
View
Comments
Will Nikola be able to keep up their momentum in the coming years until their hydrogen semi enters production? Will they continue with their hydrogen approach or transition to fully electric? Will their vehicles ever actually get to production? So many questions left to be answered.
INFOGRAPHIC

===
Infographic: EVBite; Note: an earlier version of this article appeared on EVBite. EVBite is an electric vehicle specific news site dedicated to keeping consumers up-to-date on any developments in the ever-expanding EV landscape.
Source: Evannex
We want your opinion!
What would you like to see on Insideevs.com?
Take our 3 minute survey.
- The InsideEVs team
Share this Story
- (https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?url=https%3A%2F%2Finsideevs.com%2Ffeatures%2F430705%2Ftesla-semi-versus-nikola-semi%2F&text=Nikola%27s%20Hydrogen%20Truck%20Vs.%20Tesla%27s%20Electric%20Semi&via=InsideEVs)
- copy
GO TO COMMENTS
(
)
Got a tip for us? Email: tips@insideevs.com
View all comments ( )
Trending

Lucid Is Slashing $15,000 Off The Gravity, But The Deal Won’t Last Long

The Remnants Of The Electric Saab That Never Was Are Going Up For Auction

What We Both Thought After Driving The Rivian R2

Aptera Finally Built Its First Car For Customer Delivery
Latest Stories
- The U.S. Let Volvo Keep Selling Cars. Polestar Got A No. What About Mercedes? Nov 22 - News -
- Tesla FSD V15 Makes Your Drive Look Like Grand Theft Auto Nov 22 - News -
- Waymo Is Recalling Its Robotaxis Because They're Not Great At Dealing With Human Instructions Nov 21 - Autonomous Vehicles -
- This EV-Swapped 1967 Porsche 912 Has 300 HP And A Split Battery Pack Nov 21 - News -
- This Plug-In Hybrid SUV Towed A Boeing 747 On Only 2 Wheels. Yes, Really. Nov 21 - Towing -
- BYD's Latest SUV Can Hide Its Steering Wheel When You Don't Need It Nov 20 - China -
- What We Both Thought After Driving The Rivian R2 Nov 20 - Podcast -
RECOMMENDED FOR YOU

It’s Official: The Cybertruck Is One Of The Greatest Flops In Automotive History

Waymo Is Recalling Its Robotaxis Because They're Not Great At Dealing With Human Instructions

People Are Mad About The Jeep Recon's 222-Mile Range. Here's What They're Missing

This EV-Swapped 1967 Porsche 912 Has 300 HP And A Split Battery Pack

Genesis' First Few EVs Didn't Blow Me Away. The GV90 Flagship Did

This Plug-In Hybrid SUV Towed A Boeing 747 On Only 2 Wheels. Yes, Really.

EV Reveals Have Gotten Way, Way Too Drawn Out. The Ford Fathom Proves It