Home

News

Tesla or GM: Who Has The Best Battery Thermal Management?

Tesla or GM: Who Has The Best Battery Thermal Management?

George Bower George Bower

By: George Bower

Dec 4, 2015 at 1:00pm ET

Add InsideEVs as a preferred source in Google

Share

Comment

Thermal Management Systems Play A Larger Roll As Charging Levels Increase

Coming In 2018, The Audi Q6 e-tron Quattro Will Be Taking 150 kW Charges

It could be argued that a battery’s Thermal Management System (TMS) is equally as important as the battery cell chemistry. The battery cell’s life depends on the TMS.

As we go to higher and higher charging power levels (shorter recharge times) the TMS plays an even bigger role in rejecting even larger amounts of heat. Tesla’s super chargers are already at 120 kw with 150 kw planned for the future. Audi has announced a production vehicle to compete with Tesla that has 150 kw charging. Audi has also announced a US charging network based on 150 kw charging.

So the stage is set for higher and higher charging levels. With that in mind, let’s look at Tesla’s and GM’s thermal management systems.

When evaluating a battery TMS we need to keep in mind some parameters used to compare the systems:

-Simplicity -Cost -Ability to remove heat (BTU/sec)

Tesla

Tesla’s thermal management (as well as GM’s) uses liquid Glycol as a coolant.  Both Gm’s and Tesla’s systems transfer this heat to a refrigeration cycle and use electric resistance heating in cold weather. Glycol coolant is distributed throughout the pack to cool the cells. Considering that Tesla has 7000 cells to cool this is a challenge.

Turns out Tesla has a patent app for their system. It is based on a ribbon shaped metallic cooling tube that snakes thru the pack. A sandshot from the patent app is presented below.

Tesla gm cooling gb slide 1

 

This ribbon shaped cooling tube interfaces with the cells as shown below.

Tesla gm cooling gb slide 2

Now let’s look at one module in a Tesla Model S pack (16 modules total). The cooling ribbon snakes thru the cells as shown below.

Tesla gm cooling gb slide 3

What do you think?

View

Comments

Simple: Yes. Cost effective: Yes. Ability to remove heat:  Pretty good.

General Motors

GM uses prismatic (rectangular) shaped cells. Each cell is roughly the size of a children’s book. Sandwiched between the cells is an aluminum cooling plate.

Slide: Courtesy GM

There are 5 individual coolant paths passing thru the plate in parallel not in series as the Tesla system does. Each battery pouch (cell) is housed in a plastic “frame” The frames with coolant plates are then stacked longitudinally to make the entire pack.

Illustration: Karl Reque via <a href=

Simple: Yes. Cost effective: Yes. Ability to remove high heat loads: GM’s system is slightly better than Tesla’s system in our opinion. However, in the grand scheme of things both Tesla and GM’s system have one big drawback. The heat transfer coefficient of Glycol leaves room for improvement.

We want your opinion!

What would you like to see on Insideevs.com?

Take our 3 minute survey.

- The InsideEVs team

Share this Story

GO TO COMMENTS

(

)

Got a tip for us? Email: tips@insideevs.com

View all comments ( )

Trending

Lucid Is Slashing $15,000 Off The Gravity, But The Deal Won’t Last Long

Lucid Is Slashing $15,000 Off The Gravity, But The Deal Won’t Last Long

The Remnants Of The Electric Saab That Never Was Are Going Up For Auction

The Remnants Of The Electric Saab That Never Was Are Going Up For Auction

What We Both Thought After Driving The Rivian R2

What We Both Thought After Driving The Rivian R2

Aptera Finally Built Its First Car For Customer Delivery

Aptera Finally Built Its First Car For Customer Delivery

Latest Stories

RECOMMENDED FOR YOU



The Best EV Lease And Finance Deals In November 2026



Hyundai’s N Vision 74 Was One Of The Coolest Car Designs In Recent Memory. Now It's Shelved



The 2026 Chevy Silverado EV Trail Boss Makes No Sense. I Loved It Anyway



The Remnants Of The Electric Saab That Never Was Are Going Up For Auction



The 2027 Chevy Silverado EV Gets A Power Bump And A NACS Port



This Might Be The World's First Rivian R2 With A Two-Inch Lift, And It Looks Badass



GM's Future Cars Will Be Very Different. Here's Everything We Learned