Teslas Have Cheapest 10-Year Maintenance Costs: Consumer Reports

Tesla beats out Toyota on estimated maintenance and repair costs, according to a new study.

Two men perform maintenance on a white Tesla Model 3 inside a Tesla service facility.

Tim Levin

By: Tim Levin

Apr 24, 2024 at 3:26pm ET

Add InsideEVs as a preferred source in Google

Comment

A Tesla may be your best choice if you want to save cash on maintenance and repairs over a vehicle's lifetime. A new study from the nonprofit outlet Consumer Reports found that Elon Musk's electric vehicles cost less to maintain over a 10-year period than cars from any other brand.

Tesla owners typically spent just $4,035 over a decade, Consumer Reports found. That's an average of $403.50 per year.

Get Fully Charged

The Cost Of Owning An Electric Car

Electric cars tend to cost more upfront than their conventional counterparts. But they can make up for that higher initial outlay with lower maintenance, fueling and repair costs over time.

The findings mirror what we already know about EVs. Since electric motors and batteries have far fewer moving parts than internal combustion powertrains, they require less regular maintenance. There's also a lower potential for things to break, so EVs tend to be more reliable.

That's what Steven Elek, Consumer Reports’ program leader for auto data analytics, believes is at play here. Owners of older Teslas may need to replace something costly like a battery pack, but that's rare, Elek told InsideEVs. Issues tend to be more common and more expensive in other luxury cars like BMWs, he said.

Get the best news, reviews, columns, and more delivered straight to your inbox, daily.

back

Subscribe For more info, read our Privacy Policy & Terms of Use.

To arrive at the ranking, Consumer Reports asked car owners how much they spent on maintenance and repairs in the last 12 months. By analyzing the results for vehicles in the 2014 through 2023 model years, researchers were able to estimate maintenance and repair costs for each brand over a five-year and 10-year span. They used the 75th percentile figures to approximate typical costs.

Buick and Toyota came after Tesla, tied at $4,900 for 10-year costs. The bottom nine spots were dominated by luxury brands. Land Rover brought up the rear with a long-term maintenance bill of a whopping $19,250. Consumer Reports cautions that the early ownership costs are impacted by warranties.

Here's the full ranking, arranged by 10-year maintenance and repair costs:

Brand 5-year costs 10-year costs 1. Tesla $580 $4,035 2. Buick $900 $4,900 3. Toyota $1,125 $4,900 4. Lincoln $940 $5,040 5. Ford $1,100 $5,400 6. Chevrolet $1,200 $5,550 7. Hyundai $1,140 $5,640 8. Nissan $1,300 $5,700 9. Mazda $1,400 $5,800 10. Honda $1,435 $5,835 11. Kia $1,450 $5,850 12. Dodge $1,200 $6,400 13. Jeep $1,100 $6,400 14. Chrysler $1,600 $6,500 15. Volkswagen $1,095 $6,530 16. Cadillac $1,125 $6,565 17. Ram $1,470 $6,670 18. Lexus $1,750 $6,750 19. GMC $1,400 $7,200 20. Subaru $1,700 $7,200 21. Mini $1,525 $7,625 22. Acura $1,800 $7,800 23. Infiniti $2,150 $8,500 24. Volvo $1,785 $9,285 25. BMW $1,700 $9,500 26. Audi $1,900 $9,890 27. Mercedes-Benz $2,850 $10,525 28. Porsche $4,000 $14,090 29. Land Rover $4,250 $19,250

Another takeaway Consumer Reports noted: Four of the five top brands are American.

To be sure, this study is narrow. It doesn't include other recurring costs like fuel and insurance. And it excludes collision-related repairs, which can be higher for EVs. Hertz decided to dump a large portion of its Teslas in part because of higher collision-repair costs. Due to inflation, ownership costs will be higher over the next 10 years than the study suggests, Elek said. For that reason, he said consumers should pay more attention to the ranking than the dollar figures.

What do you think?

View

Comments

Still, the research makes a good case for buying an EV—and a Tesla in particular.

Do you have any thoughts about long-term EV ownership costs? Drop your thoughts in the comments below, or contact the author: tim.levin@insideevs.com

More EV News

We're At This Year's Beijing Auto Show. What Do You Want To Know?