Home

News

Six EV SUVs Were Driven Until They Died. The Winner Was Clear

Mat Watson of CarWow pushed crossovers from Porsche, Polestar, Ford, Tesla, Audi and Kia to their limits.

CarWow EV SUV Range Test

Photo by: InsideEVs

Tim Levin Tim Levin

By: Tim Levin

Dec 6, 2024 at 10:00am ET

Add InsideEVs as a preferred source in Google

Share

Comment


We here at InsideEVs live for electric vehicle range tests, whether they’re our own evaluations or ones done by other intrepid outlets. And we know you, dear reader, love this stuff as much as we do. 

In the real world, practically nobody will actually run their EV down to a 0% state of charge. You’d have to be looking for trouble to do that. But it’s fascinating to learn which models actually live up to their advertised range estimates—and which can drive the farthest when push comes to shove. 

Mat Watson, of the CarWow YouTube channel, pushed six electric SUVs to their limits in a recent video, and the results are fascinating. He and his team drove the EVs across the United Kingdom until they wouldn’t go another inch. It’s so rare to pit several cars against one another under identical circumstances—the same weather, same route, same day—making this test a real treat. 

YouTube video player

Here are the contenders CarWow tested:

Let’s get something out of the way upfront. CarWow is a British channel, so all the vehicles are European-spec. And all the range estimates quoted are according to Europe’s testing standards, which are more generous than the EPA figures we’re used to in the States. 

Still, we think this test is enlightening for American buyers, since most of the vehicles are available in the U.S. The Ford Explorer EV—based on the same Volkswagen platform as that brand’s ID.4—is the only one that isn’t. (America's Explorer is bigger and gas-powered.)

Ford Explorer EV production start in Cologne, Germany

The European-market Ford Explorer EV.

For the range test, the CarWow team charged each SUV up to 100% and set off. They drove at the posted speed limit with the climate control set to 68 degrees, only slowing down to maximize range once the vehicle’s state of charge reached an alarmingly low level. So, basically, they tried to act like a normal driver probably would. 

For all the details and a deeper dive on each vehicle, check out CarWow’s 50-minute video. Or keep reading for the results and our take on them. First, check out the final numbers, along with each vehicle's battery size and range as provided by CarWow. CarWow says it tested the longest-range version of each car, which suggests they're all the single-motor, rear-wheel-drive variants. So it's a level playing field on that front. 

Model  Battery Size Observed Range Observed Efficiency Advertised Range (European WLTP cycle) % of Advertised Range Achieved Polestar 4 94 kWh 333 miles 3.5 mi/kWh 372 miles 90% Porsche Macan 95 kWh 318 miles 3.5 mi/kWh 386 miles 82% Tesla Model Y  75 kWh 294 miles 3.8 mi/kWh 373 miles 79% Ford Explorer EV 82 kWh 291 miles 3.8 mi/kWh 374 miles 78% Kia EV6  80 kWh 280 miles 3.4 mi/kWh 347 miles 81% Audi Q4 E-Tron  77.4 kWh 268 miles 3.5 mi/kWh 336 miles 79%

It’s not a shocker that no vehicle matched its range rating, since the test was done at highway speeds and that sucks more energy than city driving. Plus, few cars will ever hit their WLTP figures because that cycle is so generous. The Polestar 4—a strange Chinese crossover with no rear window—blew away the competition in terms of absolute miles driven and the percentage of its range rating it achieved. A whopping 333 miles is an excellent result, as is delivering 90% of its WLTP range. 

Motor1.com INSIDER - logo

Get our very best news, reviews, hot takes and more delivered straight to your inbox.

 

back

Subscribe For more info, read our Privacy Policy & Terms of Use.

The Porsche Macan came in second, driving nearly as far. And the two top spots make perfect sense, given that the Polestar and Porsche pack the largest battery packs at 94 kilowatt-hours and 95 kWh, respectively. Those are some beefy batteries. 

Despite being the oldest and arguably stalest of the bunch, the Model Y held its own quite nicely, traveling nearly 300 miles and claiming third. That’s despite having the smallest battery pack at 75 kWh. So, just because Tesla hasn’t updated the Model Y since it came out, don’t count it out; Elon Musk’s company still makes some highly competitive and efficient cars. 

2024 Porsche Macan EV

2024 Porsche Macan EV.

Interestingly enough, the Ford Explorer matched the Model Y almost exactly in range and tied it in efficiency. Plus, it looks pretty darn cool. (Hey, Ford, maybe you should bring that thing to America? Think about it.) 

Speaking of, what these range tests often underscore is just how absolutely crucial EV efficiency is. Big range numbers are great. But you know what’s even better? Lots of range from a modest battery pack. That’ll save you money on upfront cost, reduce energy costs over the long term and reduce your carbon footprint too. 

This SUV test also highlights how much more efficient sedans are, thanks to their lower weights and slipperier shapes. CarWow did a similar test with six sedans earlier this year, and the results were way better pretty much across the board. 

Tesla Model 3 Performance 2024

Tesla Model 3 Performance.

Photo by: Tesla

The Tesla Model 3, equipped with a 75-kWh pack, went 352 miles and notched an efficiency of 4.7 mi/kWh. The Mercedes-Benz EQE traveled a bladder-busting 357 miles. Of course, this may have had to do with the weather or road conditions on that particular day, but the body style surely has something to do with it too. 

What do you think?

View

Comments

What cars do you want us to range-test in the future? Any other tests you want to see? Let us know in the comments below. 

Got a tip about the EV world? Contact the author: tim.levin@insideevs.com

More EV Range Stories

‘Terrible’: Rivian’s Longest-Range EV Tested For Its Road-Tripping Abilities

Extended-Range EVs Are The Next Big Thing. Will Drivers Plug Them In?

2025 Porsche Taycan 70-MPH Range Test: Way Better Than Advertised

2025 Lucid Air Pure Falls Short Of EPA Range In 70 MPH Range Test

2024 Chevrolet Silverado EV Goes 441 Miles In Highway Range Test

Tesla Model 3 Performance Beats EPA Estimate In Range Test

We want your opinion!

What would you like to see on Insideevs.com?

Take our 3 minute survey.

- The InsideEVs team

Share this Story

GO TO COMMENTS

(

)

Got a tip for us? Email: tips@insideevs.com

View all comments ( )

Trending

A Tesla Model Y Without A Steering Wheel Is Coming: Musk

A Tesla Model Y Without A Steering Wheel Is Coming: Musk

Rivian’s Also Spinoff Pauses Deliveries Of Its $3,500 E-Bike After Months Of Delays

Rivian’s Also Spinoff Pauses Deliveries Of Its $3,500 E-Bike After Months Of Delays

Genesis Is Finally Getting Into The U.S. Hybrid Market

Genesis Is Finally Getting Into The U.S. Hybrid Market

Americans Bought More Used EVs In October. Fewer Of Them Were Teslas

Americans Bought More Used EVs In October. Fewer Of Them Were Teslas

Latest Stories

RECOMMENDED FOR YOU



A Tesla Model Y Without A Steering Wheel Is Coming: Musk



Rivian’s Also Spinoff Pauses Deliveries Of Its $3,500 E-Bike After Months Of Delays



Tesla Just Bumped The Cheapest Model Y’s Range, But The Price Stays The Same



The EV Charging Company That’s Quietly Conquering America Is Building A New U.S. Factory



Tesla Just Killed Its Cheapest All-Wheel-Drive Model Y



The BMW i3 Has The Nurburgring Skills To Match Its Impressive Range



America's Top 3 SUVs Are About To Be Hybrid Or Electric