Automakers Call For Gradual Tax Credit Phase-Out Instead Of Trump’s Rug Pull

Automakers warn that a rug-pull of the EV tax credit will cost jobs and raise prices.

Trump EV tax credit

Photo by: InsideEVs

Rob Stumpf

By: Rob Stumpf

Feb 11, 2025 at 5:27pm ET

Add InsideEVs as a preferred source in Google

Comment

Automakers are uncertain about the future of the Inflation Reduction Act and the EV tax credit.
If it's repealed, manufacturers are calling for a multi-year phase-out.
An instant repeal could cost the U.S. thousands of jobs and billions of dollars, plus an uncertain future of American position in the global EV race, they argue.

Automakers have spent the last few years betting billions on the EV race. New factories, robust supply chains and big battery plans peppered not just across the globe, but also planted deep within America's auto manufacturing belts. But now, with President Trump at the helm and Tesla CEO Elon Musk on a wild cost-cutting mission across the government, the EV tax credit is poised to be gutted.

Needless to say, manufacturers are scrambling to soften the blow that Trump warned could be coming since before he was elected in November. The latest pitch? According to Bloomberg, automakers are petitioning the federal government that if the repeal of the Inflation Reduction Act is inevitable, just don't pull the rug out on them. Instead, they're asking for elements like the EV tax credit to be phased out over several years.

Trump EV tax credit

Photo by: InsideEVs

To be clear, this is a delicate dance. Automakers need to stay on Trump's good side—especially with the U.S. government playing a game of tariff-chicken with Canada and Mexico. But these manufacturers also can't just ignore the fact that incentives for their most competitive EVs could disappear overnight.

Executives at General Motors and Ford have been making the rounds in Washington to advocate for automakers. For example, GM CEO Mary Barra recently met with Trump to discuss tariffs and how administrative policies could affect the U.S. auto industry. Ford CEO Jim Farley is slated to meet with Congress this week—his second trip to Washington in three weeks—to talk business.

“We have the potential repeal of various IRA elements,” said Farley at an investor conference in New York on Tuesday, according to Bloomberg. “We’ve already sunk capital. And many of those jobs will be at risk if the IRA is repealed, [if] big parts of it [are] repealed.”

A Slow Exit

It would seem that the auto industry really isn't sure what's going to happen with the IRA, including the EV tax credit. They have been hedging their respective bets, though. Hyundai was one of those companies that significantly upped its spending on political lobbying when Trump vowed to nuke EV subsidies last year. But an uncertain future means continuing to pressure those passing the laws for a potentially favorable outcome.

The argument being made isn't just about the free money automakers are getting (although that may certainly sweeten the deal). Car companies made big decisions based on the promise of government funding and if that goes away, the industry could be in a world of hurt.

A gradual phase-out would allow automakers time to lower EV costs. Battery prices are a prime example. While they're slated to continue to fall through the top of the decade, the battery pack still makes up a significant chunk of an EV's cost. Certain EVs are only competitive because of the tax credit, meaning that eliminating the incentive could result in car companies making the decision to take a huge loss on the model, or maybe to simply discontinue it entirely.

Toyota North Carolina Battery Plant Construction

Keeping the credits in place may also protect thousands of jobs. The battery belt—the stretch of states between the midwest and southeast U.S. that benefit from new and planned battery factories—has become a hub for EV manufacturing. Many of these jobs have come into fruition simply because the IRA's tax incentives. Should those incentives go away without warning, those jobs could be at risk. Data from the American EV Jobs Alliance shows that the U.S. has invested $200 billion to create 200,000 EV-related jobs across 12 states (meaning, an average cost of $1 million per position).

An instant repeal would also put the U.S. at an even further disadvantage in the ongoing EV spat between the U.S. and China. The IRA helped to build a more robust supply chain that utilizes domestic manufacturing and sourcing, reducing the reliance of Chinese components and battery materials. A sharp rise in cost and looser sourcing requirements could lead to an influx of Chinese EVs in the U.S.—something that the IRA (and tariffs) were meant to protect against.

"It's messed up. But I would say, if you must eliminate it, have a ramp down," said Kia America COO Steve Center, in an interview with InsideEVs in November. He continued: "A lot of other companies have spent a lot of money trying to comply with the regulations. Don't keep changing the regulations."

Is Anyone Listening?

Assembly of Volkswagen’s ID.4 electric SUV at the Chattanooga, Tennessee, vehicle manufacturing plant

Automakers are pleading, but it's unclear if Trump or Congress are actually listening.

Trump hasn't hid his skepticism towards EVs and EV-related subsidies. And his bubbling bromance with Elon Musk, who also called for ending all subsidies, doesn't inspire confidence that the tax credit is sticking around.

House Republicans are will be essential deciding whether or not key pieces of the IRA are repealed. This leaves automakers to play defense and convince lawmakers of the IRA's necessity. There's evidence they may be hesitant to repeal, it though: 19 of the 25 major automaker battery and manufacturing plants being stood up are in GOP-controlled congressional districts. Many of the remaining plants, according to Bloomberg, are in states that supported the Trump presidency in the November election.

Get the best news, reviews, columns, and more delivered straight to your inbox.

back

Subscribe For more info, read our Privacy Policy & Terms of Use.

What do you think?

View

Comments

Should the IRA be repealed or cut in an official capacity, it will likely come as part of a reconciliation bill. This means that lawmakers will be forced to weigh the benefits of the job losses against Trump's priorities and campaign promises.

Automakers know they're walking a thin tightrope. EV production needs to keep moving forward and executives need to do what they do best: lead in uncertain times. The current administration seems eager to roll back incentives, but if done too quickly, EV adoption could be stalled, jobs killed and the U.S. auto industry left behind while the rest of the world pushes forward. If it does happen, automakers will have no choice but to adjust quickly or risk losing billions in investments that can't be easily walked back.

More Politically-Charged EV News

Why The Auto Industry Is Now Ground Zero For A Tariff War

Rivian CEO Sounds Alarm On Trump's Tariffs: 'Inflation Could Be Damaging'

Tesla Leans Hard On The Tax Credits That Elon Musk Wants To Cut

Tesla, Two Other Brands' EV Sales Are Most Driven By Tax Credits

We want your opinion!

What would you like to see on Insideevs.com?

Take our 3 minute survey.

- The InsideEVs team

Share this Story