BMW i8: Long-Term Review


Screen Shot 2016-07-04 at 7.43.44 AM

Part 2: 2014 BMW i8, Drivers Long Term Review

2014 Electronaut Edition BMW i8
Delivered, January 2015
Odometer, 14,396

*Editor’s Note: Check out Part 1 here.

The BMW i8 is a Master’s work of industrial artistry, but is it a Supercar?

By “Old Testament” petrol metrics the answer is no. However a quick look at the supercar wiki shows that the definition of what is a Supercar has been in constant evolution.

In the evolution into electric mobility, a Supercar is defined for many as: A car that breaks existing boundaries, limited to just a tiny fraction of a percent of the cars on the road. A car that represents the future in the present. A car that inspires and captivates with a rarity of awe and inquiry wherever it travels. A car that offers exceptional rare beauty, sustainability, materials, performance and road handling. A car that is timeless and treasured for generations.

In the “New Testament,” the BMW i8 is most certainly a Supercar.

In January of 2015, the first model year 2014 BMW i8 Electronaut Edition found it’s way into our garage. The question was: Do I drive the i8, or will it be a garage queen? If I drive it, I could be depriving myself of a good chunk of the monetary value “when, not if” it becomes a highly prized collectible. If it’s a garage queen stored for posterity and profit, I could be depriving myself of several years of glorious experiences on the open road “when, not if” my time on earth is done.

Screen Shot 2016-07-04 at 7.35.06 AM

I came down on the side of drive it. The plan is to drive our BMW i8 for five or six years roughly 40k or 50k in miles, fix any battle scars and then put it up on a lift to be used only for that rarest of weekends or road trips.

Supercars are masculine. They’re powerful, angular, snarling, some seemingly bordering on evil. After driving and living with the i8, I find the i8 to be a mixture of mostly feminine qualities. Sexy, sculptured, goddess like, exotic, and hard to understand with many personalities (own it ladies.) Perhaps it’s the swan like wings of the opened doors, or the flying C pillar reminiscent of a models long flowing hair.


The juxtaposed allure of the BMW i8’s feminine traits and diverse personalities is why in my opinion, the car is so spell binding to so many.

The i8 has many driving personalities, one moment, stealthily, powerfully slow like a Puma without sound, stalking it’s prey. One moment, incredibly thrifty and conservative, briskly able to multitask like a coupon cutting, store hopping shopper. One moment, fierce and fast, hyper-aggressive, poised, lunging and running at full speed, poetry of form, sound and speed.

Of the three main driving modes, my favorite is slowly city cruising in stealth mode to a restaurant or hotel. When button pressing into stealth mode, I always make the swoosh sound as the car becomes silent, moving my hand palm down away from my body. Cracks me up that I do that but it’s the closest thing to piloting the Millennium Falcon this side of Tatooine. The Kessel run in less than 12 parsecs seems doable in the BWM i8.

Screen Shot 2016-07-04 at 8.17.18 AM

I’m a 54 year old “big guy” at 6’3”and 325 pounds. After an awkward first try or two (it’s awkward for everyone,) I have no problems getting in an out of the i8. With its long doors, it’s very easy to swing the legs in and out and the seating position once in the car is perfection. To get out, it’s an easy one leg out, pop up and exit the car to the rear so as not to bang the head on the door now overhead. Surprisingly it’s one of the easier cars for me to get in and out of.

Our i8 has had no repairs, service issues or faults. It’s been bulletproof. I bring the i8 into BMW of Vista on a monthly basis for a hand wash and occasional detail. The car has had a scheduled service at 12,000 miles, and new tires at 14,000 miles.

Servicing the i8 in the future should be at much lower cost than its competitive class. The electric bits, somewhat detuned (ironic I know) from the BMW i3, will require little to no maintenance, the 3 cylinder engine from the Mini should be easy to service. Remember that the engine has only 9000 miles on it, for the other 5000 miles it has just been a passenger along for the ride. Tires are affordable and brakes are longer lasting as a plug in hybrid with regen.

Wear and tear on the car is unnoticeable. The interior of the i8 is as it left the showroom with no blemishes or wear marks at all. The Terra leather interior is firm, no wrinkles cracks or sags with every inch of the front interior richly appointed in the best leather. The exterior is factory fresh with one racetrack war-wound collected on a high-speed downhill on camber right-hander. I got too close at the apex and while compressed, just kissed the inside track curbing. In that nanosecond of painful sound, I curbed the front passenger wheel slightly as well as grinding a small mark on the lower front fascia and just behind the passenger side front wheel.


It happened on a track so it’s well earned. A wheel expert and a few new plastic pieces and she will be perfect once more. I’ll wait a few more years before replacing, as I’m sure I’ll pick up one or two more scars.


Our driving patterns with the i8 are primarily in two modes. We drive the i8 locally around San Diego North County in all electric mode. Most of our favorite places are within 5-10 miles or less and with a 15-mile real world electric range this covers many of our trips. We plug in L2 charging every time the car is parked in the garage. Approximately 5,000 miles of driving has been in this electric mode, with the BMW i8 averaging 90 miles per gallon.

Our daily work driving and mid range trips are typically done in our BMW i3s or an electric bike.

The other mode is long distance driving in comfort mode. The i8 is a beautiful and comfortable grand touring car, it’s like flying on the road in a gulfstream jet. Plenty of room for gear for two between the rear storage area and the back seat. We’ve done a four state 2000 mile tour though Arizona, New Mexico, Nevada and California, a few 1500 mile trips to Napa and a trip or two to Arizona and points east. Approximately 9,000 miles of driving with no plugging in has been in this mode, the i8 averaging 30 mpg.

Combined, we are averaging 48 mpg. That’s a stunning number for a car in this class. In the near future shifting to higher density batteries, I’m sure this number will continue to go up as the electric range increases.


Here’s a snapshot of life with the BMW i8 from a recent trip to Palm Desert. Julie and I were celebrating our anniversary with a dinner at Mastro’s on the El Paseo. The valet line up in front of the restaurant was a new Mercedes AMG GT S, our BMW I8 and a Bentley Mulsanne. While we were inside eating dinner, the valet needed to put cones on both side of our i8 as folks were coming up to the car and leaning on the car to look into the windows. I asked about the other two cars not having cones? The valet’s response was “no problem with those two.”

It’s like the other cars just disappear. Still think the BMW i8 is not a Supercar?


In sport mode going through the gears with the paddles is orchestral with the brap-brap of the turbo’s wastegate harmonizing with the changing octaves of the rpm’s. Yes the sounds are amplified and piped into the car. With the acoustical isolation of the cabin, this is a welcome addition.

There’s a space like sense of speed as the front electric motor pulls you out from the turn or away from a stop with 100% torque applied at the first revolution, then joined by the 3 cylinder turbo once spooled up in rpm’s, thrusting you forward in a manor that feels unworldly, entirely unique to the all wheel drive, front electric motor – rear gasoline engine setup. This is a vehicle architecture shared by only four cars in the world, the BMW i8, the McLaren P1, the Porsche 918 and the Ferrari LaFarrari.

Screen Shot 2016-07-04 at 7.46.17 AM

To all my brothers and sisters of the pure gasoline BMW M world who think going electric is as awesome as catching the flu, note that the Plugin Hybrid McLaren P1 just shattered the track record at the Goodwin Festival of Speed with a lap time of 47.07 seconds, a full 2.2 seconds faster than the previous record holder.

From a pure performance perspective, looking at Goodwin and Le Mans, there is no doubt that the future for the next few decades lies in the architecture of carbon fiber, all wheel drive, plug in hybrid with an ever increasing electric motor torque and horsepower, and torque vectoring control. The BMW i8 is on the vanguard of that architecture.

0-60 in the BMW i8 is officially 4.2 seconds. Car & Driver has it at 3.6 seconds, Road & Track at 3.8 seconds. I clock it at around 12 parsecs. Top speed is electronically limited to 155 and the i8 get’s there quickly.

I’ve tracked the M3, 4 & 5 cars and the BMW i8 at the BMW M school in Thermal. I’ve won the “coveted blue cone” (it’s all about who gets the 3 inch blue cone and the time sheet to take home) with a lap time of 27.36 just a few tenths off the M school all time best, so I get the cars.


Is the BMW i8 a track car? No, it’s a grand touring car. The BMW i8 is shy a few hundred horsepower, needs more lateral grip and a stiffer suspension. It can keep pace with the M3 and is just a tad slower than the improved M4 around the track. That’s not a criticism of the BMW i8, it’s not set up as an M or track car.

When I express that the BMW i8 could use more horsepower and grip, what I’m really saying is that there is so much more room at the untapped top end for this car. I look at the empty rear seats and say “oh man what if!”

I’d love to track this car with a stiffer and lower suspension, meaty rubber, carbon ceramic brakes, and a few hundred extra horsepower on both axels. I’m quite sure the men and women of M could considerably up the ante in a matter of months if given the chance to do so. The BMW i8 chassis and architecture is simply that good.

Actress Paula Patton, who stars in the film "Mission: Impossible - Ghost Protocol," waves after she was assisted out of the BMW i8 hybrid-electric concept vehicle by Ludwig Willisch, president and CEO of BMW North America, during the North American debut of the i8 and the i3 electric-concept vehicle at the LA Auto Show in Los Angeles November 16, 2011. REUTERS/Danny Moloshok (UNITED STATES - Tags: TRANSPORT BUSINESS ENTERTAINMENT)

In a life well led with priorities met, there is room for indulgences. So it is with the 2014 Electronaut Edition BMW i8 in our garage. I remember seeing the BMW i8 concept in person at the 2011 LA Auto Show, it was a dream car, something unreal.

Just 5 short years from the prototype 2009 BMW Mini-E to the 2014 BMW i8. I’m now living in my own dream, how cool is that?

We’re going to drive to old age together.

Bravo BMW.

Part 3 of the long term review will cover the BMW i3

*Editor’s Note: This post appears on Peder’s blog. Check it out here.

Categories: BMW, Test Drives

Tags: , , ,

Leave a Reply

22 Comments on "BMW i8: Long-Term Review"

newest oldest most voted

Or just buy a P90DL for less money and get better performance. Oh, and actually have a true electric car…

You are missing the point Peder is making. As any true American muscle car, the P90DL is goog in straigth line. Throw in a tight curve and it will show it’s true nature.

Peder is talking about the car lines, the driving dynamics, the exotic material it is made of, the engineering behind it.

There are other cars out there that make sense, that will bring more people to the EV world. Any car that can do EV miles is a good car, Peder is actually showing for some people, you don’t need to carry a big battery to reduce your carbon foot print by 40%, 70%, 90%. Some purist can’t accept that and would prefer a lower adoption of plugins, not Peder.

I suppose racing Pike’s Peak doesn’t count for the Tesla, then? Haven’t noticed any BMW i8’s entering that race. Model S has some enviable race track qualities. Happy to list them, if you ask.
My takeaway from the article:
Superior manufacturing quality.
Back seat is suitable for cargo purposes only, and is necessary for weekend trips.
Ingress/egress requires more technique than a sedan.
Eye-catching. Should come with its own mop, for drooling onlookers and apparently the owner.
Has a bunch of driving modes I don’t understand.
Eats tires fast.
I think the thrust of the article being that hybrids are an enduring destination for top-end brands is reckless. Hybrids are intermediate, a compromise between range and battery cost/size. I hope Porsche Mission E materializes and shames BMW. $100 /kWh is a couple years away. I think what would prove the point is some enterprising soul taking a i3, upgrading its motor and battery output rate, then dishonoring the i8 on the race track.

The i8 has many qualities that the P90DL does not have.. one of them being obvious, it’s much more attractive.

Trying way too hard… this is a Car Review not a Descriptive Writing Course

I read through the first couple of paragraphs and was not sure if this was a car review or a high school writing course.

Umm, a bit cruel, but these days when anybody can write anything and have a blog the general level of quality of the written word has fallen dramatically. Which is odd as you might think the opposite would occur.

Yes, it does seem overfilled with words, hearkening back to Dickens, when publishers paid writers by the pound, not the currency, but how much their words weighed, not their weight.

I see BMW making an M variant of the i8 in the future.

As always, thanks for the great article! 😀

Why do we always have to have this “perfect vs good” debate? Any PHEV, or even hybrid for that matter, that reduces gasoline use should be our FRIEND. Sometimes non-pure-BEV options seem to be treated as enemies. Thank you Peder for a wonderful, fun report on a fabulous car. Thanks for the poetry and beauty of the report and pictures.

I have read a number of other reviews of the i8 which were much more basic, and to my way of thinking much better. This reads like one of those corporate fluff pieces on why their car is so good. Buy a Tesla instead.

Hi Peder, I enjoy reading what you write but I have to ask, why do you keep wasting your time with these hooligans?

Looks like a lot of words for something we already know which is that the i8 is in fact NOT a supercar. Sure it’s a sports car and some other things as well but one thing it is not is a supercar…

I’ve never been one to be impressed by “Raw Power”. In my teenage years when all the other boy gearheads wanted 500 hp, my ‘dream car’ was an old used 40 hp Karmann-Ghia convertible. All it had to do was go better than the speed limit, and anything more is a waste.

The I8 lends a nod to that time, because, although it has superfast acceleration, it does it with a smaller engine, battery, and motors.

So for myself currently, the Caddy ELR I have really has too much acceleration for my own good. I notice my driving style has become much more “teenage-esque”, since the car will typically beat anything next to it at a stoplight. So driving this stylish sport coupe is probably going to get me some tickets. But on the plus side it is all electric travel, and uses even less gas than the I8 described here.

All electric travel, except when on long trips that is, which is relatively rare, but often enough to make the ‘investment’ in the ‘needless’ gasoline engine much more practically utilized than many with several totally BEV’s in the garage backed up of course by a large ICE backup generator which must be exercised weekly for a power failure which in most places will never happen..

The car looks nice. I seen one in front of me as I was coming home. Had to check it out on the computer

I await the full BEV version.

“This is a vehicle architecture shared by only four cars in the world, the BMW i8, the McLaren P1, the Porsche 918 and the Ferrari LaFarrari.”

You are forgetting the Acura NSX in this statement, it’s out I just saw one yesterday while riding my bicycle.

This Article even further talks about how the NSX has a quiet OFF BUTTON, or EV mode which makes it even more apparent that it should be in your list: