Tesla Model S Earns Highest Score Ever in Consumer Reports Ratings; 99 Out of 100 (w/video)

4 years ago by Eric Loveday 26

What’s the world’s best automobile?

If you posed that question to Consumer Reports, then the answer is simple: the Tesla Model S.

Tesla Model S is Best Car Ever Tested by Consumer Reports

Tesla Model S is Best Car Ever Tested by Consumer Reports

No *asterisk required.

Consumer Reports is not only saying that the Model S is the best electric vehicle in the land.  Nope.  Consumer Reports is saying that no other vehicle it’s ever tested is even in the same league as the Model S.

To phrase it one more way, the Tesla Model S is the best all-around automobile in the world, according to Consumer Reports.

Here’s more of what Consumer Reports had to say in its full review of the Model S:

“Slipping behind the wheel of the Tesla Model S is like crossing into a promising zero-emissions future. This electric luxury sports car…is brimming with innovation, delivers world-class performance, and is interwoven throughout with impressive attention to detail. The sum total of that effort has earned the Model S the highest score in our Ratings: 99 out of  100. That is far ahead of such direct competitors as the gas-powered Porsche Panamera (84) and the Fisker Karma plug-in hybrid (57).”

 “And as you dip into the throttle, you experience a silent yet potent surge of power that will make many sports cars weep with envy.”

“With its hefty 85-kWh lithium-ion battery, our Tesla is easily the most practical electric car we’ve tested.”

Only one other vehicle ever tested by Consumer Reports scored 99 out of 100.  Care to guess which vehicle that was? (hint: it was back in 2007 and the automaker is Japanese).

via Consumer Reports

Tags: , , , , , , , ,

26 responses to "Tesla Model S Earns Highest Score Ever in Consumer Reports Ratings; 99 Out of 100 (w/video)"

  1. Spin says:

    Lexus LFA?

    1. Eric Loveday says:

      You’ve got the automaker right…but not the car

      1. Jay Cole says:

        Easy one, Toyota Land Cruiser Wagon 4WD of course

        /boom…what do I win?

        1. Eric Loveday says:

          Wrong….Completely wrong

          1. Jay Cole says:

            Frig, thought I nailed that one.

            I’m not good with those obscure vehicles that come without plugs.

            1. scottf200 says:

              Best overall: Lexus LS460 — 2009
              Price: $63,675 – $77,110
              Fuel economy: 24 highway; 16 city
              Test score: 99

  2. CR’s environmental bias is over-shadowing their reason. Here are a few things about the Model S that should be noted

    Navigation system (Topdown view, north up, only)
    Fiddly key fob
    Magic doorhandles that don’t always extend the first touch
    Huge central touchscreen without redundant buttons (historically a CR pet peeve)

  3. Eric Loveday says:

    Hopefully nobody cheats at guessing the vehicle. The answer is out there…but let’s keep this fun by not hunting down that correct answer….Guess away

    1. scottf200 says:

      You can delete my entry. I read your response after I pressed submit and you guys don’t have editing/deleting!!

      1. Eric Loveday says:

        No prob Scott…a couple others chimed in with the correct response too….had to end it at some point

  4. Josh says:

    Man, if the Q1 earnings weren’t enough, CR lands this on the next day. Sadly, I don’t have a subscription, so I didn’t read the full article they put up. I’ll grab the newsstand copy in a couple weeks.

  5. George Parrott says:

    Lada hatchback? You said not to seek external references Commisar.

    1. Eric Loveday says:

      Not the Lada…It’s a Japanese something or other….Though if I didn’t know the answer I would’ve guessed something BMW

      1. zilm says:

        Export Lada with right-wheel drive!

  6. Spin says:

    How about the Lexus 600h ?

    1. Eric Loveday says:

      Getting close…

      1. Eric Loveday says:

        It does have a few “L” letters in its name

  7. Spin says:

    GS 600h?

  8. Spin says:

    L letters!!
    GL 600h

  9. Spin says:

    LS 600h, I had to look it up!!

    1. Eric Loveday says:

      On the right track for sure…but there’s no “H” in the name of the only other Consumer Reports vehicle to score a 99

  10. Spin says:

    If it is not the regular LS 600 then I give up!!

  11. Anthony says:

    [spoiler alert]

    From USA Today – “Tesla was the first car to get a 99 score since the Lexus LS 460L tested in 2007.”

    1. Jay Cole says:

      Which if I am not mistaken is the mechanical twin of the … Toyota Land Cruiser Wagon 4WD!

      /boom x2

      …almost indistinguishable from each other

      1. Eric Loveday says:

        Which one is which?….I can’t even tell!!

  12. Scott says:

    Don’t forget folks that CR is only opinion. They say they have scientific methods, but that’s on kitchen paraphernalia, not cars. And Lexus? They made some good ones, but they utterly suck now. Especially compared to the newer metal from Detroit.